Skip to main content

Posts

'Hales, Bonaventure, and the Parisian divines': a 1796 Prayer Book commentary on the absolution in the Visitation of the Sick

It is, strictly speaking, nothing more than the precatory and declaratory forms united, and applied to a particular case. The interpretation offered by John Shepherd, in his A Critical and Practical Elucidation of the Book of Common Prayer, Volume I (1796), of the indicative form of absolution in the Prayer Book's Visitation of the Sick may strike us as odd. Is the view of 'I absolve thee' as "nothing more than the precatory and declaratory forms united" merely an attempt by Shepherd to explain away this Prayer Book provision? Rather than an attempt by a Georgian Anglican to justify his discomfort with this absolution, it is, rather, a reflection of the thought of significant medieval Latin divines.  In a footnote, Shepherd points out that the indicative form was introduced "about 1225, or 1230".  To the "more moderate and learned", he states, it seemed an "improper deviation from primitive and universal practice". It was such "...
Recent posts

The Elizabethan Settlement, Jewel's Apology, and the character of Anglicanism

On this day in 1558, Elizabeth I acceded to the throne. God, as Hooker declared, had "caused in the depth of discomfort and darknes a most glorious starre to arise, and on hir head setled the Crowne" ( LEP IV.14.7). And so began the Elizabethan Settlement. It was a fundamental event for what was to later become Anglicanism. Much of the character of later Anglicanism was defined by the Elizabethan Settlement: national churches, free of the papal supremacy; the catholic Creeds confessing the Trinitarian and Christological faith; episcopal order, with the ministry of priests and deacons; rites and ceremonies of the Prayer Book; married clergy as a joyful norm, with unmarried clergy a respected minority; laity (Crown and Parliament) participating in the governing of ecclesiastical affairs; the parish church maintained with its stained glass, font, and chancel; cathedrals with their choral tradition ("that the same so remain", in the words of the Elizabethan Injunctions...

'The prayers of the church, of which he was a great lover to his dying day': Jeremy Taylor's funeral sermon for Sir George Dalston

... the prayers of the church, of which he was a great lover to his dying day.  Thus did  Jeremy Taylor's sermon , at the 1657 funeral of the old Cumberland Royalist Sir George Dalston, describe a lay piety centred around the Book of Common Prayer. The phrase 'the prayers of the church' would have had no other meaning than this.  It was, of course, cautiously expressed by Taylor: this was during the Interregnum, with the Prayer Book prohibited by law. The Parliament had passed an ' Ordinance for taking away the Book of Common Prayer ' in January 1645, declaring that the Prayer Book "be abolished". As the recent volume Church and People in Interregnum Britain (2021) has demonstrated through local studies, a key factor in the continuation of "prayer book loyalism" throughout the Interregnum was the support given to episcopalian clergy by local elites. Taylor himself had experience of this, both in Golden Grove, through the patronage of the Earl of...

'The Chancels shall remain as they have done in times past': on reading Article XIX with - not against - the Homilies, Prayer Book, and Hooker

In a  recent post on the Church of England's attractive and fitting logo 'A Christian presence in every community', Psephizo offers a theological rationale for the logo, declaring "Presence is people, not plant". In this theological rationale the church building is merely a functional "tool" - indeed, no theological meaning for church buildings is provided. This view, we are told, is "the New Testament answer": My contention is that the phrase is a good one, but only if we recover the New Testament answer to the question: what is the presence of God in a community? The answer is not, in the first place, a building, or a PCC (!) or a vicar. It is a people. It is, Psephizo contends, the Formularies of the Church of England, and Article XIX in particular, which teach that "Presence is people, not plant": If we take Article XIX, the New Testament temple theology and our own ordinal seriously, then the question is not whether the Church o...

'With great contentment': the Aberdeen Doctors, Bishop Forbes, and the prosaic attractions of a national episcopal church

As Alexander Scrogie, one the Aberdeen Doctors, lamented the death of Patrick Forbes, Bishop of Aberdeen (1618-35), his description of Forbes' episcopal ministry pointed to how the episcopally ordered Jacobean Church of Scotland, inherited by Charles, was becoming what James had intended - a national episcopal church alongside those of England and Ireland. This was so not only in terms of the Royal Supremacy and episcopal order but also in more prosaic, local ways. Consider what Scrogie in his sermon states to be Bishop Forbes' "first and foremost care":  His first and foremost care, was for the House of GOD; and especiallie of the Cathedrall Church where hee did reside; aedifying, and reparing the ruines thereof, and furnishing it with ornamentes convenient;  This brings to mind one of the Elizabethan Homilies that 'godly' opinion particularly disliked, that ' For Repairing and Keeping Clean and Comely Adorning of Churches ': It is sin and shame to s...

'Purely ministerial': a 1796 Prayer Book commentary on the absolution in the Visitation of the Sick

Our Lord Jesus Christ, who hath left power to his Church to absolve all sinners who truly repent and believe in him, of his great mercy forgive thee thine offences: And by his authority committed to me, I absolve thee from all thy sins, In the Name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost. Amen. We have seen how John Shepherd, in his A Critical and Practical Elucidation of the Book of Common Prayer, Volume I (1796), robustly critiqued the indicative form of absolution - 'I absolve thee' - as a medieval innovation, unknown to the Primitive Church. The fact remains, however, that this form of absolution was in the Prayer Book's Visitation of the Sick, to be given to those who, being seriously ill, "humbly and heartily desire it". It is this which allows Shepherd to emphasise the very particular context in which the Prayer Book provides for use of the indicative form of absolution: The piety of the church would not refuse to any of its members at the poi...

'It is absolutely necessary that the threatenings of Almighty God be known and published': a William Paley sermon

That Sermon VII in Volume V of Paley's Works , on the text Matthew 16.26, is entitled 'The Terrors of the Lord', is certainly suggestive of the subject matter: it addresses, as Paley puts it at the sermon's opening, "the positive pain and suffering" known after death, when "happiness and reward" are forfeited. Of the various Paley sermons considered in recent weeks, this is surely the most striking.  We are, after all, talking about a sermon by the great author of Natural Theology , the celebrated divine of the late Georgian Church, assailed by evangelicals and Tractarians alike for embodying the lazy, luke-warm formalism of his era. Once again we see how this caricature - of the man and the church of that age - is nonsense. It is a profoundly serious Christianity heard from Paley in the pulpit. What is more, we know from Louis Coulson's 2011 study To Edify and Delight: Introducing the Sermons of Gilbert White of Selborne - that good Parson Whit...