'Not weighing our merits, but pardoning our offences': The Prayer of Oblation and the Prodigal(s)

When administering Holy Communion Order One (that is, the 1926/1662 rite) according the Church of Ireland Book of Common Prayer 2004 Order, I have almost always used the post-Communion Prayer of Thanksgiving ('Almighty and everliving God, we most heartily thank thee') rather than the Prayer of Oblation ('O Lord and heavenly Father, we thy humble servants'). It is the richness of the Prayer of Thanksgiving's description of partaking of the sacrament which I find particularly compelling, giving expression to a deep and joyful Reformed eucharistic theology. Presiding at a recent Order One celebration, however, I was drawn to the Prayer of Oblation. Partly it was from a desire to ensure that its place in the rite was respected; partly it was an opportunity to revisit the Prayer of Oblation after a lengthy period of relying on the Prayer on Thanksgiving. Using the Prayer of Oblation that day, however, brought me to a new appreciation for this post-communion prayer, pri...