Skip to main content

The Elizabethan Settlement, Jewel's Apology, and the character of Anglicanism

On this day in 1558, Elizabeth I acceded to the throne. God, as Hooker declared, had "caused in the depth of discomfort and darknes a most glorious starre to arise, and on hir head setled the Crowne" (LEP IV.14.7). And so began the Elizabethan Settlement.

It was a fundamental event for what was to later become Anglicanism. Much of the character of later Anglicanism was defined by the Elizabethan Settlement: national churches, free of the papal supremacy; the catholic Creeds confessing the Trinitarian and Christological faith; episcopal order, with the ministry of priests and deacons; rites and ceremonies of the Prayer Book; married clergy as a joyful norm, with unmarried clergy a respected minority; laity (Crown and Parliament) participating in the governing of ecclesiastical affairs; the parish church maintained with its stained glass, font, and chancel; cathedrals with their choral tradition ("that the same so remain", in the words of the Elizabethan Injunctions).

The description offered above may be regarded as lacking by some: what about doctrine? Specifically, what about Reformation doctrine? In seeking to respond to such a critique, we might first point out that these practices and characteristics assume significant aspects of Reformation doctrine. Marriage of clergy, for example, is accepted because "Bishops, Priests, and Deacons are not commanded by God's Law, either to vow the estate of single life, or to abstain from marriage" (Article XXXII). The Prayer Book is a vernacular liturgy because "It is a thing plainly repugnant to the Word of God ... to have Publick Prayer ... in a tongue not understanded of the people" (Article XXIII). Such practices, in other words, are clearly an expression of Reformation doctrine.

That said, perhaps the critics of the above characterisation of Anglicanism are onto something. When I think of my experience of Anglicanism, it is not the doctrine of justification by faith only which first comes to mind: indeed, to be entirely frank, I am not sure it really comes to mind at all in this regard. Now, yes, I have assented to the Articles of Religion and do indeed believe "that we are justified by Faith only" - it is, however, that this does not loom large in my understanding of the character of Anglicanism. It is not what first comes to mind when I think of my Anglican experience.

Before I am accused of betraying the Reformation heritage of Anglicanism, let me call a witness to my defence - John Jewel.  His Reformation credentials are, of course, unimpeachable. It is this which makes the description of the Elizabethan Settlement in Apologia Ecclesiæ Anglicanæ particularly interesting. Explicit articulations of Reformation doctrine do not have a significant place in his description of the reformed Church of England. Indeed, his description is not, I think, far removed from the description I gave above of the character of Anglicanism. 

Jewel begins with the Church of England's confession of the Trinitarian and Christological faith of the catholic Creeds. This, he declares, is the faith of the Church that is "catholic and universal, and dispersed throughout the whole world". He then proceeds to state that the Church of England is episcopally ordered and that, contrary to the allegations of critics, priests and deacons administer Word and Sacrament:

we believe that there be divers degrees of ministers in the Church; whereof some be deacons, some priests, some bishops; to whom is committed the office to instruct the people, and the whole charge and setting forth of religion ... Wherefore these persons do us the greater wrong, which have nothing so common in their mouths, as that we do nothing orderly and comely, but all things troublesomely and without order; and that we allow every man to be a priest, to be a teacher, and to be an interpreter of the Scriptures.

Jewel robustly affirms the episcopal authority and dignity of the bishops of the Church of England, rooted in Scripture and the practice of the Primitive Church:

For all the Apostles, as Cyprian saith, were of like power among themselves, and the rest were the same that Peter was, and that it said indifferently to them all, "feed ye;" indifferently to them all, "go into the whole world;" indifferently to them all, "teach ye the Gospel." And (as Hierom saith) all bishops wheresoever they be, be they at Rome, be they at Eugubium, be they at Constantinople, be they at Rhegium, be all of like pre-eminence, and of like priesthood. And, as Cyprian saith, there is but one bishopric, and a piece thereof is perfectly and wholly holden of every particular bishop.

He then turns to married clergy:

We say that matrimony is holy and honourable in all sorts and states of persons, in the patriarchs, in the Prophets, in the Apostles, in holy martyrs, in the ministers of the Church, and in bishops; and that it is an honest and lawful thing (as Chrysostom saith) for a man, living in matrimony, to take upon him therewith the dignity of a bishop.

At this point in his description Jewel refers to the sufficiency of Scripture for what is 'needful for our salvation'. It is interesting that he does so in the midst of his description and just after he affirms the marriage of clergy. It seems to be, perhaps, less of a doctrinal statement and more of an expression of the place of the Scriptures in the life of the Church of England - an explanation of why there are those lengthy readings from holy Scripture at Morning and Evening Prayer:

We receive and embrace all the canonical Scriptures, both of the Old and New Testament, giving thanks to our God, who hath raised up unto us that light which we might ever have before our eyes, lest either by the subtlety of man, or by the snares of the devil, we should be carried away to errors and lies. Also that these be the heavenly voices, whereby God hath opened unto us His will: and that only in them man's heart can have settled rest; that in them be abundantly and fully comprehended all things, whatsoever be needful for our salvation, as Origen, Augustine, Chrysostom, and Cyrillus have taught ...

That Jewel is here referring to the place of the Scriptures in the worship of the Church of England is further suggested by the fact that he then turns to the Sacraments and their place in the life and worship of the Church of the Elizabethan Settlement. On Baptism he provides something of a summary of the BCP Baptismal rite:

We say that Baptism is a Sacrament of the remission of sins, and of that washing, which we have in the blood of Christ; and that no person which will profess Christ's Name ought to be restrained or kept back therefrom; no, not the very babes of Christians; forsomuch as they be born in sin, and do pertain unto the people of God.

And similarly with the Eucharist - "these holy mysteries", in the words of the Prayer Book Holy Communion:

We affirm that bread and wine are holy and heavenly mysteries of the body and blood of Christ, and that by them Christ Himself, being the true bread of eternal life, is so presently given unto us as that by faith we verily receive his body and his blood.

Communion in both kinds is mentioned, again reflecting the Prayer Book practice, "Then shall the Minister first receive the Communion in both kinds himself, and then proceed to deliver the same ... to the people":

when the people cometh to the Holy Communion, the Sacrament ought to be given them in both kinds: for so both Christ hath commanded, and the Apostles in every place have ordained, and all the ancient fathers and Catholic bishops have followed the same.

The absence of elevation of the consecrated elements in the Prayer Book is similarly echoed in Jewel stating that the sacramental elements were not "solemnly carried about in procession", a practice "without the word of God, without the authority of the holy fathers, without any example of antiquity". He then provides a touching summary of what would become the enduring Anglican experience of the Prayer Book Holy Communion:

the mysteries of our redemption ought with all holiness and reverence to be executed.

Jewel also points to the "comeliness" of the ceremonies retained by the Church of England in its Prayer Book:

we keep still, and esteem, not only those ceremonies which we are sure were delivered us from the Apostles, but some others too besides, which we thought might be suffered without hurt to the Church of God: because that we had a desire that all things in the holy congregation might (as St. Paul commandeth) "be done with comeliness and in good order."

As for liturgy in vernacular, it is inherent to the nature of "common prayer":

We make our prayers in that tongue which all our people, as meet is, may understand, to the end they may (as Paul counselleth us) take common commodity by common prayer, even as all the holy fathers and Catholic bishops, both in the Old and New Testament, did used to pray themselves, and taught the people to pray too.

It is now, at the conclusion of his description of the Church of England, that Jewel turns to two key Reformation doctrines. Firstly, Christ our Mediator. As with the sufficiency of Scripture, however, the context suggests that this is less of a doctrinal statement and more of an expression of a characteristic of the worship of the Church of England, in which saints are not invoked and all prayer is offered through Jesus Christ:

Neither have we any other mediator and intercessor, by whom we may have access to God the Father, than Jesus Christ, in whose only Name all things are obtained at His Father's hand.

Finally, at the very end, Jewel turns to justification by faith only. Even here, however, the emphasis appears to be elsewhere - on the necessity of good works in the Christian life:

though we say, we have no need at all by our own works and deeds, but appoint all the means of our salvation to be in Christ alone, yet say we not, that for this cause men ought to live loosely and dissolutely: nor that it is enough for a Christian to be baptised only and to believe: as though there were nothing else required at his hand. For true faith is lively, and can in no wise be idle.

If, as I have tentatively suggested, there is a liturgical quality to how Jewel here orders the reading of holy Scripture, Baptism, Eucharist, communion in both kinds, ceremonies, and common prayer, the placing of justification at the conclusion, with the emphasis being on the necessity of faith lived out in charity, may be thought of as the sermon following divine service. Indeed, it reflects the focus 'Of the Names of the Homilies' listed in Article XXXV, the Elizabethan Homilies having a less doctrinal emphasis, concentrating on the Christian moral life, the great festivals, common prayer, and sacraments. 

Jewel's Apologia Ecclesiæ Anglicanæ, addressed to the governors and divines of Europe, was, as the title makes explicit, a defence of the Church of England. It is the ordered life of the Church of the Elizabethan Settlement that we encounter in Jewel's account. Reformation doctrine does, as we have seen, underpin these characteristics. But the characteristics are themselves what Jewel sets before European opinion - this is how Jewel shows Elizabeth's Church to Europe. In doing so, we see what I think can be regarded as much of the defining characteristics of Anglicanism. 

This brings us back, then, to how many of us experience and describe Anglicanism. We do not first turn to Reformation doctrine (and this may be true, to a greater or lesser extent, of other Churches of the Reformation). Reformation doctrine is there, part of the material that provides our foundations. Crucial as foundations are, they are not what we first think of when we experience or describe our homes.  It is much the same with our experience of Anglicanism. The material of the foundation, amongst which is Reformation doctrine, does not define our experience of the characteristics of Anglicanism. It is, rather, much as Jewel set forth: creeds, episcopacy, the ministry of priests and deacons, married clergy, sacraments, the rites and ceremonies of Common Prayer, exhortation to live "in love and charity with our neighbours".

That such an account of Anglicanism may seem to some to be doctrinally insufficient should not overly concern those of us who deeply value this Anglican experience. This is the heritage handed to us by the Elizabethan Settlement and, I suggest, set forth by John Jewel in his Apologia Ecclesiæ Anglicanæ.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Why I support the ordination of women: a High Church reflection

A number of commenters on this blog have asked about my occasional expressions of support for the ordination of women to all three orders.  With some hesitation, I have decided to post a summary of my own views on this matter.  The hesitation is because I have sought on this blog to focus on issues and themes which can unify those who identify with or have respect (grudging or otherwise!) for what we might term 'classical' Anglicanism (the Anglicanism of the Formularies and - yes - of the Old High Church tradition).  Some oppose the ordination of women (and I have friends and colleagues who do so, Anglo-Catholic, High Church, and Reformed Evangelical).  Some of us support it (again, friends and colleagues covering a wide range of theological traditions). Below, I have organised my thinking around 5 points (needless to say, no reference to Dort is implied). 1. The Declaration for Subscription required of clergy in the Church of Ireland states: (6) I promise to submit ...

How the Old High tradition continued

Charles Gore's 1914 letter to the clergy of his diocese, ' The Basis of Anglican Fellowship ', can be regarded as a classical expression of the Prayer Book Catholic tradition.  A key part of the letter - entitled 'Romanizing in the Church of England' - addressed the "Catholic movement", questioning beliefs and practices within it which tended to "a position which makes it very difficult for its extremer representatives to give an intelligible reason why they are not Roman Catholics".  Gore provides the outlines of an alternative account and experience of catholicity within Anglicanism, defined by three characteristics.  What is particularly interesting about these characteristics is their continuity with the older High Church tradition.  Indeed, the central characteristic as set out by Gore was integral to High Church claims over centuries: To accept the Anglican position as valid, in any sense, is to appeal behind the Pope and the authority of t...

The Prayer Book's theology of eucharistic consecration: Why individual cups should be rejected

The common cup may now be shared. So says the Church of England's most recent Covid-19 guidance , issued on 25th January, repeating the guidance given in December. It is, therefore, a rather odd time to renew the campaign to allow the administration of the Eucharist by means of individual cups : after all, the Covid-19 restrictions are being eased across society, the bishops have judged it appropriate to restore the Chalice to the faithful, and there is now no pressing need to consider alternatives. Unless, of course, this campaign has never really been about public health concerns but, rather, about altering Anglican eucharistic practice and theology .  The Book of Common Prayer 1662 makes clear, explicit provision for what is to happen with "consecrated Elements" remaining after the faithful receive the Sacrament: When all have communicated, the Minister shall return to the Lord's Table, and reverently place upon it what remaineth of the consecrated Elements, coveri...