'The Episcopal dignity': the Aberdeen Doctors, Bishop Forbes, and Scottish episcopal order under the Crown
Thereafter, his calling to the Episcopall dignitie, was rare, and examplarie, without his knowledge, or seeking, directlie, or indirectlie, sine ambitu and vsurpation, hunting after places and preferment, as manie doe, thorow ambition, and loue of gayne and glorie, not awayting the LORD'S calling.
What is most striking about this comment is the use of the term 'episcopal dignity' to refer to the office of bishop. To those in the Church of Scotland in 1635 opposed to episcopal order and ideologically committed to government by presbytery, the term would have been regarded as encapsulating the ministerial imparity and hierarchy they rejected. Scrogie, however, clearly has no concerns about the use of the term. Hence it is the term he uses when first referring to Forbes' episcopal appointment. It is indicates how, alongside their eirenicism, the Aberdeen Doctors were thoroughly committed to the episcopal order of the Church of Scotland.
Scrogie continues by placing Forbes' episcopal office in a two-fold context:
Onlie this I can not forbeare: Our gracious Soveraygne, of blessed memorie, did not so much honour him, as himselfe, and the age, in the freedome of his noble, and vnexpected choyse: and that Elogie which Nazianzen giveth to Saynct Basil, truelie and properlie fitteth our Bishop ... And though hee acknowledged a deepe obligation to many great and honourable friendes, yet he ought it to no thing, to no man, but to GOD'S Providence, and the King's bountie. And thus shall it be done to all them that honour GOD and the King: GOD and the King, without doubt, will honour them.
Bishop Forbes, in other words, represented an episcopacy that was both rooted in the patristic church - seen in the invocation of Gregory of Nazianzus' oration on the death of Basil - and, as he was appointed by the Crown, an episcopacy that was under the Royal Supremacy. We have previously seen how another of the Aberdeen Doctors, Robert Baron, praised Forbes as the 'Athanasius of the North'. Now Scrogie points to Forbes as the Basil of the North. In both cases, these Aberdeen Doctors were placing the Scottish episcopacy in relationship with the great bishops and episcopal sees of the early centuries of catholic Christianity.
It is, however, the reference to appointment by King James that would have been most controversial to ideological presbyterians hearing or reading Scrogie's sermon. The rejection of the Royal Supremacy would become a defining characteristic of the Covenanter tradition, insisted upon in 1689 to the consternation of William III, used to a quite different form of presbyterianism in the Netherlands. By contrast, Scrogie, in Hookerian fashion, clearly exults in the Royal Supremacy and the rightful role of the Crown in the appointment of bishops:
And thus shall it be done to all them that honour GOD and the King: GOD and the King, without doubt, will honour them.
We might here detect an echo of Hooker's acclamation:so it might deservedly be at this day the joyfull song of innumerable multitudes, yea the Emblem of some estates and Dominions in the world, and (which must be eternally confest even with teares of thankfulnesse) the true inscription stile or title of all Churches as yet standing within this Realme, By the goodnes of almightie God and his servant Elizabeth we are (LEP V, Dedication 10).
Such was the goodly order of the Church of Scotland in 1635. Under the Royal Supremacy, it stood alongside the other episcopally-ordered national churches of the Three Kingdoms. This is what was seen in appointment of Forbes to the see of Aberdeen by James VI/I; this is what was celebrated - albeit amidst his sense of foreboding - by Stogie in his sermon honouring Forbes' episcopal ministry.


Comments
Post a Comment