Harding's case for denying the Cup to the laity fundamentally rested on his interpretation of the fact that only the apostles were present in the Upper Room for the Last Supper. Bread and Cup were only required for priests. A half-communion was appropriate for the laity, therefore, for they were absent from the Upper Room.
No, proclaims Jewel. For the Lord's Supper is for all the Church, the whole Body of Christ. The Sacrament is to be common to all the people of God, clergy and laity. Christ's Blood was shed for all. Christ's Blood is spiritually partaken of by all in our salvation. The Cup is to be commonly administered to all:
Herein standeth that mystical unity, that one bread is broken unto all, and one cup is delivered unto all equally, without difference; and that, as Chrysostom saith, in the reverend sacrifice there is no difference between the priest and the people, but all is equal ...
Doubtless Christ's blood was shed indifferently for all the faithful, as well for the people as for the priest; between whom and the people, as I have before shewed out of St Chrysostom, in this case there is no difference ...
The lay-people, being faithful and godly, by faith and in their hearts do indeed and verily drink the blood Of Christ: therefore they may drink the sacrament of the same ...
Ye say, "The priests are bound Of necessity to receive both kinds, but the lay-people is not bound." And so ye conclude that Christ ordained two sundry communions, the one not like the Other; the one for the priests, the Other for the people. And therefore by your advice we must correct St Hierome, that saith, "The Lord's supper must be common to all;" and likewise Chrysostom, that saith, In the holy mysteries there is no difference between the priest and the people." For it is now otherwise agreed that the Lord's supper may not be common unto all, and that in the mysteries there must be a difference between the priest and the people ...
In the apostles, therefore, the laity no less than the clergy were indeed present in the Upper Room, addressed by Christ in the same manner:
The sum of the reason standeth thus: The apostles are commanded to receive both kinds; ergo, the people is not commanded to receive both kinds. The weakness whereof is evident, and sheweth itself. It Will much rather and better follow thus: The people is commanded to receive as the apostles received, for there is expressed no difference. The apostles received in both kinds; ergo, the people is commanded to receive in both kinds ... I trust it doth well appear that we have both the example Of Christ that ministered the sacrament in both kinds, and also Christ's institution, that bade his disciples to do the same ...
"But to minister unto the vulgar lay-people in both kinds," saith M. Harding, "was not Christ's institution." Thus he saith, and saith it often, and only saith it. Other authority than his own he bringeth none. The reason that moveth him, I ween, is this; for that there was no lay-people at that banquet with Christ, but the apostles only. But this reason would spoil the lay-people not of one part only, but of all together ...
Amongst "the great inconveniences" emphasised by those Roman commentators opposed to the Cup being administered to the laity were such concerns as:
liquor might be shed: It cannot be carried about without danger: ... The lay-people should touch the cup: Some of them have beards ... The dignity of the priest and layman should be all one.
Jewel offers a robust response to this list:
These and other like inconveniences are such as Christ and his apostles never knew.
The Supper of the Lord was instituted with no such concerns, but that the whole Body of Christ, clergy and laity alike, may be united in "the holy mysteries of Christ's body and blood":
forasmuch as this is a mystery Of unity, God grant unto us such humility Of mind, that we may all submit ourselves unto his holy word, that we may join together in holy and perfect unity.
Jewel's exposition of administering the Cup to the laity recalls us to rejoice in this gift of the magisterial Reformation, that "one cup is delivered unto all equally" - a sign of Christ's saving passion being for all, of laity no less than clergy present through the apostles in the Upper Room, of our spiritual communion with Christ's redeeming Blood, and of the Church's unity in and through the mystery of our redemption.
On Reformation Day, therefore, may we give thanks for that movement which restored the Cup in the holy Supper to the laity. As Jewel declared:
we wish and pray to God that his whole church may once be reformed after the example and institution of Christ.

A very timely article given a push by certain Roman Catholic bishops to restrict as to when lay Catholics can receive the Communion under Both Kinds. The Very Reverend John Jewel here displays a reasoned use of sola scriptura here.
ReplyDeleteYes, it is very odd - and disappointing - to see a return to communion in one kind in some RC circles. It is also disappointing that the Anglican side has not asked for this to be examined in Anglican-RC ecumenical conversations.
DeleteDefinitely and I wonder how much of that is from a backlash to Vatican II.
DeleteI think that is a key aspect of it all - an attempt to re-establish an old identity marker, despite the fact that the restoration of the Cup was grounded in patristic practice and shared with the great Churches of the East.
Delete